STARRED REVIEW
March 11, 2025

Pick-Up

By Nora Dahlia
Review by
Fans of romance audiobooks have grown accustomed to hearing from two narrators as each half of a potential couple. In Pick-Up, Nora Dahlia shakes things up by adding a third voice.
Share this Article:

Nora Dahlia’s unconventional romantic comedy, Pick-Up (12.5 hours), focuses on divorced parents interacting (and sometimes behaving even more childishly than their offspring) during drop-off and pick-up at a Brooklyn public school. Fans of contemporary romance audiobooks have grown accustomed to hearing from two different narrators as each half of a potential couple tells their side of the story, but here, Dahlia shakes things up by adding a third voice, that of “Very Involved Mom” Kaitlin, whose relationship to the protagonists is not immediately clear. Actress Gilli Messer shines as barely-holding-it-together Sasha, and Teddy Hamilton exudes warmth and confidence as her love interest, Ethan. Eunice Wong’s Kaitlin is vaguely menacing for reasons that only later become clear. Listeners who enjoy witty enemies-to-lovers romances will find much to appreciate in Pick-Up.

Read our review of the print version of Pick-Up.

Trending Reviews

Get the Book

Pick-Up

Pick-Up

By Nora Dahlia
Simon & Schuster Audio
ISBN 9781668121863

Sign Up

Stay on top of new releases: Sign up for our newsletter to receive reading recommendations in your favorite genres.